Introduction
August Wilson's Fences and Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman are two quintessential American plays that delve into the intricate layers of personal and societal struggles. Both plays, though set in different cultural contexts, share profound themes of unfulfilled dreams, familial obligations, and societal constraints. They offer a critical examination of the American Dream, revealing its complexities and the disillusionment it often brings. Through the protagonists, Troy Maxson and Willy Loman, Wilson and Miller explore the intersection of personal aspirations and the harsh realities of life. This essay will discuss the common ideas present in both plays, emphasizing the pursuit and failure of the American Dream, the impact of generational conflict, and the pervasive influence of societal expectations. By examining these themes, we can better understand how these plays reflect the challenges of their respective eras and the timeless nature of their messages.
The American Dream: Pursuit and Failure
The concept of the American Dream is a central theme in both Fences and Death of a Salesman, serving as a critical lens through which the protagonists' lives are examined. In Death of a Salesman, Willy Loman is consumed by his belief in the American Dream, yearning for success and recognition. He is convinced that personal charisma and superficial charm are keys to success. However, as Miller poignantly illustrates, Willy's unwavering faith in this dream leads to his downfall. He becomes a tragic figure, unable to adapt to the changing economic landscape and the reality of his modest achievements. Willy's demise underscores the hollowness of the dream he pursued. Scholars such as Bigsby (2005) argue that Miller critiques the capitalist ethos that equates self-worth with material success, emphasizing the disillusionment that many face when the dream remains elusive.
Similarly, in Fences, Troy Maxson's aspirations are thwarted by systemic racism and personal limitations. His dream of becoming a professional baseball player is crushed by the racial barriers of his time. Troy's sense of betrayal and frustration is palpable as he projects his unfulfilled ambitions onto his son, Cory. This transfer of dreams highlights the generational impact of the American Dream's failure. As Wilson illustrates, the dream is not equally accessible to all, and for African Americans like Troy, it is often a source of pain rather than promise. Critics like Nadel (1993) suggest that Wilson uses Troy's story to critique the racial inequities that persist in American society, challenging the notion of the American Dream as a universal promise.
Generational Conflict and Familial Obligations
Another common theme in both plays is the tension between generations, exacerbated by differing perceptions of success and duty. In Death of a Salesman, Willy Loman's relationship with his sons, Biff and Happy, is fraught with misunderstanding and disappointment. Willy projects his dreams onto Biff, hoping that his son will achieve the success that eluded him. However, Biff's rejection of his father's aspirations leads to a profound rift. According to Murphy (1996), this conflict represents the broader generational divide of the post-war era, where traditional values clashed with emerging modern ideologies.
In Fences, the generational conflict is equally pronounced. Troy's rigid expectations for Cory mirror the societal pressures he faced in his youth. Troy's insistence on controlling Cory's future stems from his own failures and a desire to protect his son from similar disappointments. Yet, Cory's resistance symbolizes a new generation's desire for autonomy and self-determination. As Wilson depicts, this struggle is not merely personal but emblematic of the broader African American experience, where familial duty often conflicts with individual aspirations. Scholars like Elam (2001) highlight how Wilson uses this theme to explore the complex dynamics of African American families, capturing the tension between preserving cultural heritage and embracing new opportunities.
Societal Expectations and Personal Identity
Societal expectations play a significant role in shaping the identities and destinies of the characters in both plays. Willy Loman is profoundly influenced by societal norms that equate success with material wealth and social status. His identity is inextricably linked to his professional achievements, or lack thereof. This societal pressure ultimately leads to his existential crisis and tragic end. Miller's portrayal of Willy's struggle serves as a critique of a society that values economic success over human dignity, a theme explored by critics like Abbotson (2007).
In Fences, societal expectations manifest in the form of racial discrimination and economic limitations. Troy Maxson's identity is shaped by the systemic barriers he faces as an African American man in mid-20th century America. His struggle to assert his dignity in a society that denies him equal opportunities is a poignant commentary on the pervasive impact of racism. Wilson uses Troy's character to expose the harsh realities of racial injustice, challenging audiences to confront the societal structures that perpetuate inequality. As Bogumil (1999) observes, Wilson's exploration of these themes underscores the resilience and complexity of African American identity in the face of adversity.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Fences and Death of a Salesman offer a profound exploration of common themes that resonate with audiences across different cultural contexts. Both plays critique the elusive nature of the American Dream, highlighting the personal and societal challenges that thwart its realization. Through the lens of generational conflict and societal expectations, Wilson and Miller examine the complexities of familial relationships and personal identity. The plays serve as a testament to the enduring struggles faced by individuals as they navigate the intersection of personal aspirations and societal constraints. By addressing these themes, the playwrights not only reflect the specific historical and cultural contexts of their time but also provide timeless insights into the human condition. Through their poignant narratives, Fences and Death of a Salesman continue to challenge and inspire audiences, encouraging a deeper understanding of the enduring quest for meaning and fulfillment in the face of adversity.
Did you like this example?
Yes
No
Cite this paper
Common Themes in Fences and Death of a Salesman.
(2022, July 08). Edubirdie. Retrieved March 4, 2025, from https://hub.edubirdie.com/examples/common-ideas-in-fences-and-death-of-a-salesman/
“Common Themes in Fences and Death of a Salesman.” Edubirdie, 08 Jul. 2022, hub.edubirdie.com/examples/common-ideas-in-fences-and-death-of-a-salesman/
Common Themes in Fences and Death of a Salesman. [online].
Available at: <https://hub.edubirdie.com/examples/common-ideas-in-fences-and-death-of-a-salesman/> [Accessed 4 Mar. 2025].
Common Themes in Fences and Death of a Salesman [Internet]. Edubirdie.
2022 Jul 08 [cited 2025 Mar 4].
Available from: https://hub.edubirdie.com/examples/common-ideas-in-fences-and-death-of-a-salesman/
copy
Stuck on your essay?
